What can you substitute for tomato juice?

In the brief guide, we will address the query, “What can you substitute for tomato juice?” and other additional information on how tomato juice can be substituted perfectly. 

What can you substitute for tomato juice?

The other substitutions for tomato juice are as follows:

  • Tomato sauce
  • Tomato soup
  • Tomato paste
  • Canned tomatoes
  • Fresh tomatoes
  • Ketchup
  • Vegetable broth

Tomato sauce

Tomato sauce is a good choice because it matches tomato juice in terms of texture, flavor, and color. Substituting tomato juice with tomato sauce will help to allow the dish to retain the same flavors. 

Additionally, tomato sauce can be commonly found in the kitchen. Tomato sauce is an ingredient that is used as the main ingredient in many recipes. Dilute the tomato sauce to equal the portion of tomato juice. 

Tomato soup

The texture of tomato soup and the flavors it imparts will only result in enhancing the flavors of the dish that required tomato juice. The tomato soup should be thinned down to match the consistency of tomato juice. 

Use one part soup and three parts water to reduce the overpowering flavors of the tomato soup. When tomato soup is used, one should bear in mind that it is already processed; therefore, the cooking time can be reduced as well. 

Tomato paste

Yes, tomato paste is a good alternative and we highly recommend it. Tomato paste does not come with added flavors; hence, it will be a good substitute. This will help the dish to remain intact in terms of its flavors. 

Again, when you choose to use tomato paste as a substitute for tomato juice, it has to be diluted and thinned down to match the consistency of tomato juice. This will allow the flavors to stay the same.

Canned tomatoes

Yes, canned tomatoes are a good substitute for tomato juice as well. To match the texture of the tomato juice, the canned tomatoes should be ground to a smooth proportion. It is very unlikely that canned tomatoes will affect the flavor of the dish. 

As canned tomatoes will lack the sweetness tomato juice contains, additional sweeteners can be added to the mix. This will balance out the missing flavors from the canned tomatoes. 

Fresh tomatoes

Fresh tomatoes will be the best substitute for tomato juice because the flavors are the same. The desired consistency, the tanginess, and the sweetness of the tomato juice can be balanced out by the freshly blended tomatoes. 

The freshly ground tomatoes will allow the dish to remain the same without contributing additional flavors that could impact the dish. 


Ketchup can be used as an alternative to tomato juice, but when ketchup is used, the acidic flavor can influence the outcome of the recipe. It is important that ketchup is diluted to thin down the consistency and reduce its strong flavors. 

One part of ketchup should be mixed with six parts of water to balance out all the empowering flavors in the dish. It is a good substitute and can be used in times of emergencies. 

Vegetable broth

Yes, vegetable broth can be used as a substitute for tomato juice. This is a good substitute for a liquid replacement. The tomato flavor may be missing, but if the dish needs a liquid base, then the vegetable broth will do the trick. 

It might differ in terms of color and texture, but the flavor of the vegetable broth will be a perfect substitute for tomato juice. Use the right amount of vegetable broth in the dish, keeping in mind the flavor and the consistency.

The bottomline!

Based on the above substitutions we have added, making the right choice depends on the dish that is being cooked as well. Choose based on the importance of the ingredients, such as the texture, consistency, and flavors. 

Understanding the purpose of each ingredient in the recipe will allow you to make a better choice. Matching flavors and textures should be the goal when choosing one of the given substitutes so that the change is unnoticeable.

Other FAQs about Juice that you may be interested in.

How to know if the juice is spoiled

How To Preserve Juice For Sale

What is the substitution for lemon juice?


In this brief guide, we have addressed the question, “What can you substitute for tomato juice?”. We have added information to make sure there are multiple options for you to choose from to substitute tomato juice. 

Leave us your experience in the comment section below to let us know the substitute that was chosen instead of using tomato juice. 



Hi, I am Charlotte, I love cooking and in my previous life, I was a chef. I bring some of my experience to the recipes on this hub and answer your food questions.