What can I substitute for old bay seasoning?

In this brief article, we will answer the question, “What can I substitute for old bay seasoning?” with an in-depth analysis of the old bay seasoning, and the possible substitutes of the old bay seasoning.

What can I substitute for old bay seasoning?

Old bay seasoning can be best substituted with crab boil, pickling spice, Cajun seasoning, Todd’s dirt, seasoned salt, Chinese five-spice, and copycat old bay seasoning.

Old bay seasoning

Old bay seasoning is a variety of American spice blend which is herbaceous, salty, peppery, and spicy. Old bay seasoning is a spice that makes a delicious combination with seafood items such as shrimp boils, oyster chowder, and clam.

Substitutes for old bay seasoning

If you have run out of old bay seasoning, no need to worry. Below we have mentioned different substitutes for old bay seasoning that give the same texture and flavour to the dish. 

Crab boil

Crab boil is an ingredient that is a substituted product for old bay seasoning which is used in water in which crawfish, crabs, shellfish, lobster are boiled. This product is present all over the United States, that can be purchased online or from the stores. 

Both spices are used in equal quantities such as one ratio one for both crab boil and original product old bay seasoning.

Pickling spice

Pickling spice is another substitute for the old bay seasoning which is used to add the taste and flavours in soups and stews. This is the substituted product for pickling the food. It is also considered as one of the perfect alternate seasoning products for shrimp boils and to give flavour and taste to seafood.

These pickling spices are available online and also in the spice section of markets. It can also be formed at home by using different spices which are available at home. To prepare a good pickling spice make a mixture of allspice, mustard seed, cloves, cilantro seeds ginger, red pepper flakes, and bay leaf.

In quantity both the spices should be used in equal content.

Cajun seasoning

Cajun seasoning is a substituted product for old bay seasoning which usually originated from Louisiana. It is also considered a perfect substitute. It is available both in supermarkets and online. In flavour and taste these both spices are approximately equal.

The ingredients which are common in both the substitute and the original product include pepper, paprika, garlic powder, oregano, and cayenne pepper. If someone likes to take a meal with fewer spices, then he is suggested to take another substituted product for the old bay seasoning rather than Cajun seasoning.

Todd’s dirt

Todd’s dirt is a good substitute for old bay seasoning in most of the recipes which require a good content of spices. Crabby dirt is one of the ingredients in Todd’s dirt which is hot and fiery in taste and flavour that could also be used in recipes as a good alternative for old bay seasoning.

Crabby dirt also has quite a similar taste to Todd’s dirt. In the composition of Todd’s dirt, some of the ingredients are additionally added such as cayenne, and chipotle powder. These two ingredients are a whole source of spices in the meal.

Seasoned salt

Seasoned salt is also one of the substituted products for old bay seasoning. Seasoned salt is a cheap content that is available in every grocery store. This is also one of the most accessible ingredients. 

But it is only recommended at that time in our recipes when we have to replace the old seasoning bay equal to a pinch or we can say in a very little bit content. 

Seasoned salt as a substituted product for old bay seasoning has quite a different taste. It is mostly used in seasoning different products such as pork, fish, poultry, or beef. It is a flavorful sprinkle seasoning over the eggs and popcorns. Seasoned salt as a substituted product enhances the taste and flavour of recipes.

Chinese five-spice

Chinese five-spice is another substituted product for the old bay seasoning. But it is recommended that when someone doesn’t like the taste of old bay seasoning completely, he should try the Chinese 5 spice with a totally different taste alternative product. 

Chinese five-spice is a blended mixture of cloves, fennel, star anise, cinnamon, and Szechuan peppercorns. This is also considered as a sweeter taste and it is a versatile content that is suitable for seasoning in seafood, poultry, and red meat.

We hope that the list above brought additional insight on what to substitute the next time you run out of old bay seasoning. But, if you personally prefer the real thing, that is perfectly fine, too!

Conclusion

In this brief article, we have answered the question, “What can I substitute for old bay seasoning?” with an in-depth analysis of the old bay seasoning, the benefits of old bay seasoning, and what are the possible substitutes of the old bay seasoning.

References

https://www.cuisinevault.com/old-bay-seasoning-substitutes/
https://enrichenthekitchen.com/best-old-bay-seasoning-substitutes/

Hi, I am Charlotte, I love cooking and in my previous life, I was a chef. I bring some of my experience to the recipes on this hub and answer your food questions.