What can I substitute for horseradish?

In this brief guide, we will answer the question “what can I substitute for horseradish?” with an in-depth analysis of what can be substituted for horseradish. Moreover, we will also discuss the effects of substituting horseradish with its substitutes on the recipes.

What can I substitute for horseradish?

Several options in the market can be substituted for horseradish. Some of them are:

  • Wasabi 
  • Brown mustard 
  • Fresh ginger 
  • Black radish 
  • Horseradish sauce 

They all work well in place of horseradish. Although these alternatives taste similar, some of them look much different. Keep this in mind when deciding which ingredient is the best for your dish. 

How wasabi or wasabi paste can be substituted for horseradish?

Wasabi paste is the best option for replacing horseradish as they share a similar flavor profile and are from the same Brassica family. Outside of Japan, most wasabi paste is a mix of horseradish and green coloring, so the difference between the two is minimal.

What makes wasabi slightly ineligible for being used as a substitute for horseradish?

The main problem with wasabi is its vivid green pigment that may not be suitable for some dishes. If you’re serving roast beef with a cream sauce, then the green shade will look out of place. For most other recipes though, wasabi will do the job nicely.

How much wasabi to use when substituting for horseradish?

Some wasabi can pack a punch so test with a small amount and increase if necessary.

Does wasabi pose any health risk when used in place of horseradish?

Yes, it does. If you’re looking for a backup option because of allergies, then avoid wasabi in root or paste form as it is closely related to horseradish.

Can brown mustard be used as a horseradish substitute?

Brown mustard makes a good horseradish substitute because it is hot, intense, and also because it is spicy. The kick it delivers is similar to that which you get with horseradish. The spicy kick in brown mustard is the same compound that also gives wasabi and horseradish its spicy nature.

How much brown mustard can be substituted for horseradish?

Use equal quantities of brown mustard as horseradish when substituting brown mustard for horseradish.

What makes mustard a better substitute for horseradish than wasabi?

The use of mustard as a horseradish substitute is extremely versatile. For example, if the recipe that you’re using calls for freshly grated horseradish, you can use mustard seeds instead.

Can fresh ginger be substituted for horseradish?

Yes, it can. Fresh ginger has a unique flavor that is a mix of earthy, lemony tastes. It starts to warm up slowly on the tongue but isn’t anywhere near as hot as horseradish. 

It does not come from the same family or have the same taste but makes a good replacement. 

How much ginger should be used to replace horseradish?

When replacing horseradish with ginger, use a bit more ginger but don’t overuse it.

The flavor of the dish could start to taste unpleasant if too much ginger is used. Your best option is to use rather small amounts of ginger as compared to horseradish and accept that the heat will be less than the original recipe.

How does black radish make a good substitution for horseradish?

Imitating the taste of horseradish is possible with black radish. 

The black radish has a dark reddish-black colored skin and looks similar to beetroot in color, shape, and size. The flesh inside is white and crispy, offering a spicy, hot flavor. 

It has similarities with horseradish which means that it can be used as a replacement. Also, the heat of the black radish is in the skin, so if you remove it you’ll reduce the heat.

How much black radish can be substituted for horseradish?

When replacing black radish for horseradish use equal amounts for a ratio of 1:1.

Can any radish be used as a substitution for horseradish?

Any radish can be used as an alternative to horseradish. For a milder option, choose a daikon radish or the standard red variety.

How can horseradish sauce be used as a horseradish substitute?

Horseradish sauce that comes in a bottle from the grocery store can be substituted for horseradish. Don’t expect to generate the same flavor from a packaged product; it will be noticeably less.

How much horseradish sauce should be used to substitute horseradish?

You’ll probably want to use 1.5 times the fresh quantity but as with all the other substitution choices, use a small quantity, taste, test and increase if necessary.

Conclusion:

In this brief guide, we have answered the question “what can I substitute for horseradish?” with an in-depth analysis of what can be substituted for horseradish. Moreover, we have also discussed the effects of substituting horseradish with its substitutes on the recipes.

Citations:

https://www.spiceography.com/horseradish-substitute/
https://www.mashed.com/201508/heres-what-you-can-substitute-for-horseradish/
https://onthegas.org/food/horseradish-substitute/

Mahnoor Asghar is a Clinical Nutritionist with a bachelor's degree in Nutrition and Dietetics. She is compassionate and dedicated to playing her part in the well-being of the masses. She wants to play a fruitful role in creating nutrition and health-related awareness among the general public. Additionally, she has a keen eye for detail and loves to create content related to food, nutrition, health, and wellness.