The Real Difference Between Buttermilk and Heavy Cream

In this article we’ll take a look at ‘the real difference between buttermilk and heavy cream’. We will also answer the related queries like can buttermilk be substituted, different types of buttermilks and the substitutes of buttermilk and heavy cream. 

What is The Real Difference Between Buttermilk and Heavy Cream?

One of the major differences between buttermilk and heavy cream lie in the manufacturing method, taste and ingredients. The real difference between buttermilk and heavy cream are summarize in the table below: 

Buttermilk (cultured) Heavy cream 
Making Made by adding bacterial culture to skimmed milk Made by setting whole milk and the cream rising out on the surface 
Fat content 1-2%36-40%
Taste Acidic and tangy flavorSweet and rich taste 
Consistency Thickener in comparison to milkHeavy and thick 
Color yellowishWhite 

Can I substitute buttermilk for heavy cream?

Generally speaking, yes, you can substitute buttermilk for heavy cream. However, this substitution varies with the recipe and flavor requirements of the end products. For instance buttermilk carries an acidic taste. If your recipe demands a sweet and sugary flavor then butter milk is not a good substitute for heavy cream. 

How to substitute buttermilk for heavy cream in baking?

In order to substitute buttermilk for heavy cream. You can use ⅔ cup of milk and ⅓ cup of oil in the recipe. For a less acidic taste you can use ¾ cup of milk and ¼ cup of melted butter in the recipe. 

What is the difference between old fashioned buttermilk and cultured buttermilk?

Old fashioned buttermilk is the by-product that is left after the churning of butter. When whole milk is allowed to set, cream separates out on the top. Ingredients left behind are whey and butter. After the butter has been churned out of the mix, what is left behind is a buttermilk. It is acidic to taste and contains lactic acid. In consistency it is very light and frothy. 

Commercial grade buttermilk that is most commonly available in the market is made by adding pure culture of lactobacillus bacteria to the skimmed milk. Bacteria cause the fermentation that leads to the development of tangy flavor and thicker consistency as compared to milk. Cultured buttermilk does not contain butter and the fat content is minimal. 

How to make heavy cream without fat? 

 In order to make heavy whipping cream you will need two tablespoons of cornstarch for 1 cup skimmed milk. Add cornstarch to the milk and mix. Whip it quickly to prevent the formation of a lump. Corn Starch acts as a thickening agent and whipping will add to the result. 

Whip until a thick cream-like consistency is achieved. In this way you can make heavy cream without added fat. However, it is important to remember that its taste and texture will be very different from the fat added cream. 

Is whipping cream the same as heavy cream? 

Yes, whipping cream and heavy cream are the same in most aspects. When it comes to the fat content heavy cream is richer and contains more fat as compared to the whipping cream. In addition to that there is a slight difference in the texture of whipping cream because of whipping.

Whipping cream tends to give a lighter and softer texture to the dishes while heavy cream adds richness and volume and holds its shape for longer.  Apart from these minor differences, whipping cream and heavy cream are almost identical. 

What are the substitutes of buttermilk? 

Buttermilk is difficult to substitute when it comes to baking. It is because of the tangy flavor, acidic content and low fat. In order to substitute buttermilk you can use whole milk with added lemon juice. 

Take one cup of whole milk and add 1 tablespoon of lemon juice in it. Let it sit for some time around fifteen to twenty minutes. Buttermilk is ready to use when it starts to curdle. 

What are the substitutes of heavy cream?

Which substitute to use instead of heavy cream depends on the recipe. However, it is noticeably that heavy cream is more easily substituted as compared to the buttermilk in any recipe. The reason behind is the availability of several ingredients with the same consistency and fat content as heavy cream. 

Some of the substitutes of heavy cream include evaporated milk, cream cheese, soured cream, whey, cottage cheese, and whole milk. In case you are looking for vegan options that choices include soy milk, coconut milk,olive oil, corn starch in vegan milk.

Other FAQs about Buttermilk that you may be interested in.

What Can You Substitute For Buttermilk?

What can i substitute for buttermilk

What Can You Substitute For Buttermilk?

Conclusion 

In this article we looked at ‘the real difference between buttermilk and heavy cream’. We  also answer the related queries like can buttermilk be substituted, different types of buttermilks and substitutes of buttermilk and heavy cream,

References 

https://difference.guru/difference-between-buttermilk-and-heavy-cream/

Hi, I am Charlotte, I love cooking and in my previous life, I was a chef. I bring some of my experience to the recipes on this hub and answer your food questions.