Freshly vs Dinnerly (+9 Features of each)

This info-rich blogpost will be checking out the features and characteristics which are present in Freshly, along with those which are present in Dinnerly. Both of these platforms are meal delivery services which aim to bring convenience and ease to their users. While Freshly focuses more on health and nutrition, Dinnerly focuses on affordable meal kits as its USP.

In the end, we will give you our opinions on which of these three may be the better choice based on first-hand experiences.

Freshly vs Dinnerly

In the table below, the advantages, as well as limitations which are present in Freshly and Dinnerly have been clearly depicted for your use. You will also be able to see the delivery areas of these meal delivery services, along with the types of recipes which are offered here.

 Feature  Freshly Dinnerly
 Delivery areas  98% of the United States aside from Alaska & Hawaii  98% of the United States aside from Alaska & Hawaii
 Price range  $8.49 to $11.49 per week  $35 to $67 per week for two
 Price per plate  $8.49 per plate minimum $4.99 per plate
 Difficulty levels  Easy Easy
 Avg. cooking time  3 minutes 30 minutes or lesser
 Avg. calorie count  400-500 calories per serving 800-900 calories per serving
 Supporting material  Nutritional information Only digital recipe cards
 Recipes supported  Gluten-free,Dairy-free,Plant-based,Carb-smart,Calorie-conscious  Vegetarian,Dairy-free,Low carb,Gluten-free,Healthy,One-pot,Kid-friendly 
 No. of choices  12 per week 28 per week
 Introductory deal  $100 off on first four orders 60% off on first box, 20% off on next two
 Avg. shelf life  5-7 days,Longer while frozen  3-5 days for meat, 4 days for veggies

Types of Plans: Freshly vs Dinnerly

 Freshly  Dinnerly
 4-5 meals per week $11.79 per portion + shipping   Two-Person box $6.39 per portion + $9.99 shipping,2 or 3 or 5 or 6 meals per week 
 6-7 meals per week $9.99 per portion + shipping  Family box $5.69 per portion + $9.99 shipping,3 or 4 or 5 or 6 meals per week  
 8-9 meals per week $9.49 per portion + shipping    
 10-11 meals per week $9.29 per portion + shipping   
 12 meals per week $9.99 per portion + shipping  

Freshly has a number of plans for the customer to choose from based on the needs and requirements of their household. The user is also free to add more meals to their plans. The recipes in Freshly cover a variety of dietary needs such as dairy-free as well as gluten-free. Low-carb options are also available in Freshly for anyone trying to keep the weight off.

Dinnerly also has a number of plans for the customer to choose from. the plans in Dinnerly mainly come in two sizes, the two-person box and also the family box which is superb for large households. While Dinnerly is certainly quite affordable, it still does not back down on the quality and quantity of ingredients, which is highly appreciable.

Winner: Freshly wins the Types of Plans segment.

Types of Ingredients: Freshly vs Dinnerly

  Ingredient type   Freshly  Dinnerly
 Produce   US-based vendors Farm-fresh produce
 Meat, eggs, fish  Free from fillers, chemical additives and even preservatives  NAE chicken,Antibiotic free meat 
 Other ingredients  None Seasonings,Sauces 

Freshly offers only the best ingredients in its meal kits. This meal delivery service tends to favor local vendors and partners to create the meals. The produce mainly comes from family-run farms which are guaranteed to use very safe farming practices. The meat, eggs, and fish are all free from fillers, chemical additives and preservatives.

Dinnerly also works the same way when it comes to sourcing its ingredients. The produce and fruit are sourced from family-run farms who tie up with this meal kit delivery service. The meat is antibiotic-free and hormone-free. The meal kits in Dinnerly come with the right amount of seasonings and sauces for the customer to use in their cooking.

Winner: Freshly and Dinnerly win the Types of Ingredients segment.

Add-Ons: Freshly vs Dinnerly

 Freshly Dinnerly 
 Proteins,Sides  Dessert,Breakfast 

When it comes to add-ons, both of these platforms hugely disappoint. In Freshly, the customer is able to choose from only a limited variety of add-ons such as extra proteins in the form of chicken breasts and learn beef. In addition to this, the customer can also choose from healthy sides for their meals.

Dinnerly also does not have a ton of variety when it comes to add-ons. The add-ons in Dinnerly include breakfast items which can be added to the meal box to help customers start their day on the right note. Desserts are also available in Dinnerly as add-ons which can be simply added to the cart while placing the order.

Winner: Dinnerly wins the Add-ons segment.

Packaging of Meal kit: Freshly vs Dinnerly

 Freshly  Dinnerly
 Meal box,Denim insulation,Non-toxic ice packs  Meal box,Separator,Ice packs,Box liner,Bottles,Containers,Bags 
 Fully recyclable  Fully recyclable

Freshly places a ton of importance on the recyclability of the packaging of the meal box. The meal box itself is made of mostly recycled cardboard and this can be recycled curbside. To preserve the freshness of the food inside, the meal box is insulated with denim and filled with ice packs which use a non-toxic gel.

Being a meal kit delivery service, Dinnerly uses a lot more packaging. Nevertheless, the elements of the packaging in Dinnerly are pretty sustainable and very eco-friendly. The meal kits in Dinnerly come with separators, bottles, containers and bags, all of which can be easily recycled curbside.

Winner: Freshly and Dinnerly win the Packaging of Meal kit segment.

Customer Support: Freshly vs Dinnerly

 Feature  Freshly Dinnerly
 Chat support  + –
 Email support  + +
 Phone support  + +
 Availability  All days of the week All days of the week

If the customer is facing any issue in Freshly, they can easily contact the customer support through one of many ways. The best and easiest way to reach out for assistance in Freshly is through the live chat feature. As an alternative, the customer can also reach out through email support along with phone support which is present on all days of the week.

Dinnerly also has an excellent customer support system. However, one drawback of this is that there is no live chat feature in this meal kit delivery service. As an alternative, the customer can reach out through email support and also phone support which is available throughout the year, barring certain public holidays.

Winner: Freshly wins the Customer Support segment.

Sample Meals: Freshly vs Dinnerly

 Sample  Freshly Dinnerly
 Sample 1  Name: Steak Peppercorn with Sauteed Carrots & French Green BeansCalorie count: 500Heating time: 3 minsSpice level: Mild   Name: Keto-Friendly Smoky Paprika SteakPreparation time: 20-30 minsSpice level: MediumDifficulty: Easy 
 Sample  2  Name: Sausage Baked Penne with Sauteed Zucchini & SpinachCalorie count: 470Heating time: 3 minsSpice level: Mild  Name: One-Pot Tomato Ravioli with Basil PestoPreparation time: 20-30 minsSpice level: MildDifficulty: Easy 
 Sample  3   Name: Protein-Packed Chicken Parm with Mozzarella & Garlicky BroccoliCalorie count: 410Heating time: 3 minsSpice level: Mild   Name: Crispy Ranch Fish SticksPreparation time: 40-50 minsSpice level: MildDifficulty: Easy 

Freshly has a variety of recipes which can easily fit into anybody’s dietary requirements. The recipes cover both comfort foods which are instant crowd-favorites, but also cover international cuisines for more variety. More importantly, the meals in Freshly are healthy and come with the right balance of nutrition and taste.

Dinnerly’s meal kits come with recipes which also cover plenty of dietary requirements, such as keto diets and vegan diets. The recipes are very easy to follow and can be covered in a few steps of instruction. The spice levels of the recipes in Dinnerly are also numerous to cater to the palate preferences of various users.

Winner: Freshly wins the Sample Meals segment.

App rating: Freshly vs Dinnerly

 Platform Freshly  Dinnerly
 Google Play Store 4.4 4.6 
 Apple App Store  4.8 4.7
 TWP Rating  4.5/5 4/5

Final Verdict: Freshly wins this battle because of its high ease of use and plenty of variety.

The main advantage of using Freshly is that the meals do not need to be cooked at all since they come fully prepared. The meals in Freshly cover a variety of cuisines and are made of the best ingredients. The seasonings and sauces are already included in Freshly and thus the user does not have to lift a finger when they want to eat.

Dinnerly offers very affordable meal kits and thus has become popular among the masses. The reason for Dinnerly’s popularity not only lies in its affordability, but also the ease of cooking, since most recipes can be prepared in about 4-5 steps. The recipes cover various cuisines as well as different diets.

Between Freshly and Dinnerly, Freshly takes the crown, since the meals arrive fully prepared and only need a little heating in the microwave or the oven. The ingredients are also very fresh and combined in a smart manner to bring nutrition along with a variety of tastes to the customer’s dinner table.


To bring you the best reviews of each and every meal delivery service, we spoke to testers and real life users, reviewed the information provided by each service on their respective websites, carried out primary research on social media platforms and checked out the user reviews of these platforms on various social media sites. We have also used the reviews presented by current users of these services on their respective Google and Apple apps.

We are currently conducting our own internal review and we will update this page with videos and pictures of our experiences. If they differ extensively from what our external reviewers said then we will update this post so you get both points of views and can decide which service provider is more suited to your needs based on the information above.

The main types of criteria which we have used in order to assess and evaluate these meal delivery services is the simplicity of the recipes, the variety of meals in the service, the inclusiveness of diets and cuisines and even the supporting material.

In addition to these, we have also highly taken into regard the sustainability and recyclability of the packaging of these services. Lastly, we have also considered the delivery services and customer services of these platforms.

Frequently asked questions: “Freshly vs Dinnerly”

How long do Freshly meals last?

Freshly meals last for five days to seven days when they are stored in the fridge. The user can also choose to store them in the freezer where they can last for several more weeks. Freshly clearly indicates the meals which contain ingredients which need to be eaten first, such as seafood.

Are Freshly meals fully cooked?

Yes, Freshly meals are fully cooked. Since they arrive fully cooked, the customer only needs to heat them in a microwave for a few minutes. As an alternative, they can heat the meals in a conventional oven as well, while this may take a little longer.

Is Dinnerly a good deal?

Yes, Dinnerly is a good deal. The meal kits in Dinnerly are not only pretty affordable but contain very tasty and healthy meals which can suit the needs of the entire family.

If you like this blogpost, please leave your comments and questions below.


Hi, I am Charlotte, I love cooking and in my previous life, I was a chef. I bring some of my experience to the recipes on this hub and answer your food questions.