Can you replace butter with margarine in cookies?

In this brief guide, we will answer the question “ can you replace butter with margarine?” with an in-depth analysis of the reason for the replacement of butter with margarine in cookies. Moreover, we will also discuss what effects are produced by the replacement of butter with margarine in cookies.

Can you replace butter with margarine in cookies?

Yes, butter can be replaced by margarine in cookies. Butter can be changed with the aid of margarine in cookies. But relying upon the recipe, the number of fats with regards to other components, and the temperature you bake at, margarine will affect the unfolding and texture of the very last result.

What makes butter an integral ingredient in baking?

Butter is the principal component in nearly all traditional baking recipes. It’s used for loaves of bread, truffles, cakes, cookies, cupcakes, bread, and so on.

In most recipes for cakes, cupcakes, and quick bread, the process of creaming butter with granulated sugar is extremely crucial to attaining the even-rising, rich, spongy texture that characterizes these products.

 It is all through the 3 to 5 mins of thrashing the sugar into the butter till it’s miles “fluffy” that the sugar granules aerate the dense fats. This gives cakes a rich texture and flavor to also rise.

Unsalted Butter vs. Margarine

Most baking recipes call for unsalted butter, and all of the soy margarine and shortenings we’ve encountered are not unsalted. To account for this disparity, reduce the amount of salt in a given recipe employing 1/four teaspoon consistent with half cup margarine.

The best substitute for butter other than margarine:

If you need to maintain just one ingredient to replacement for butter needs to be coconut oil. 

Coconut oil is superb for use in pretty much the whole lot, from baking to stove-top cooking to spreading on toast. It’s wholesome, rich, and tastes scrumptious.

 It cuts down on saturated fats and may not alternate the taste of meals an excessive amount of. It is also a more healthy opportunity to canola oil.

Types of margarine:

There are two major categories of margarine:

  •  Tub margarine:

Margarine bought in plastic tubs has an incredibly similar flavor and texture to softened or whipped butter. Beyond the feel, a key difference between bath margarine and butter is that, the decreased content of saturated fats and higher in water. 

In baking, melted margarine ought to work in recipes that name for melted butter, but in recipes,  that name for softened butter, swapping in bathtub margarine may additionally change the texture; as an instance, desserts could be less soft, and cookies will commonly spread out extra and be less crisp.

Tumargarinees are too tender for pies, pastries, and different recipes that call for cold butter, and don’t get up in icings and frostings, both. 

Low-fats/light kinds of margarine tend to be inappropriate for cooking and baking because of excessive water content.

  • Stick margarine:

Stick margarine, additionally referred to as a block or difficult margarine, has the same texture as that of butter, and is, therefore, a higher substitute for baking and cooking than bathtub margarine. However, stick margarine is generally high in trans fat, which is bad for our hearts.

You can read butter vs. margarine, which is healthier here.

Other FAQs about Margarine which you may be interested in.

Can u use margarine instead of butter for cookies?

How to substitute margarine with butter?

Difference between cookies made with butter and margarine:

Butter melts truly gradually compared to different baking shortenings available.

It can enhance the cookies’ consistency and texture via reaching a well unfold out and crispier cookie. That’s additionally the motive why you get to have a fudgier or gooey cookie.

 Whereas,  margarine acts the identical duty, but, considering that butter has more water content and lesser fat in comparison to butter. 

Expect that when substituting butter with margarine, the cookies are thinner because of too much spreading out and will flip out crispier than the same old. It’s like a biscuit kind of texture if you’re trying to evaluate it. Favored by using maximum people.

Nutritional benefits of margarine over butter:

Margarine generally tops butter concerning heart fitness

Margarine is made from vegetable oils, so it carries unsaturated “top” fat, polyunsaturated and monounsaturated fats. These sorts of fat help reduce low-density lipoprotein (LDL), or “terrible,” LDL cholesterol when substituted for saturated fats.

But whilst you’re baking, butter triumphs over margarine on every occasion. For cakes, cookies, and pastries, butter (unsalted, that is) presents a richer flavor. Margarine, which can incorporate more water and less fat may additionally make thin cookies that unfold out even as baking (and may burn). Butter is also the higher desire for frying


In this brief guide, we have answered the question “ can you replace butter with margarine?” with an in-depth analysis of the reason for the replacement of butter with margarine in cookies. Moreover, we have also discussed what effects are produced by the replacement of butter with margarine in cookies.


Was this helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!