Can icing go bad?

In this short article, we will provide an answer to the question “can icing go bad?”, types of icings and we will also discuss the storage method of homemade buttercream frosting.

Can icing go bad?

Yes, icing can go bad. The manner frosting is handled has an impact on how long it will last on the shelf. Keeping the pantry and cupboard at 70 degrees Fahrenheit or below increases the chance that cake icing will be able to reach its full shelf-life potential. To keep a constant temperature and moisture level in the pantry, close any windows. Always use clean equipment, and keep any remaining icing in an airtight container to prevent bacteria from growing. Anything that seems unusual smells funny, or tastes strange should be thrown away.

Types of Icings

Spread icing

It is produced and packed in plastic cans that are stored on a shelf or in a cabinet until it is required. In most cases, this product may be used for about three months beyond the expiry date shown on the box, which is typically the time during which the product should be sold or eaten. This kind of icing or frosting should be refrigerated after it has been opened. If stored correctly, it may be used for up to two or three weeks after it has been opened. Avoid contaminating the container with cake crumbs to ensure safe storage.

Dry mix icing

Dry cake icings that are sold in cartons or pouches are often prepared from a premixed recipe. By Lesley Fisher and Lydia Medeiros of the Ohio State University Extension website, they may be kept for about eight months. Keeping icing and frosting mixes in a cool, dark, and dry environment can help to extend their shelf life significantly. Moisture has the potential to cause the powdered mixture to clump and deteriorate over time. Due to temperature changes, storing the mix on a shelf that gets direct sunlight for a part of the day may result in condensation forming within the box when the box is opened. Any frosting that is leftover from the recipe should be refrigerated immediately after being made.

Squeeze the tube

Two types of cake icing are available in convenient squeeze tube formats: conventional ornamental icing and a gel-based alternative. Both of these have the potential to last indefinitely. When traditional cake decorating icing gets stale, it hardens and loses its ability to perform its intended purpose. The efficacy of the gel decreases as the gel fades. It gets too runny to hold its shape any longer. It is suggested that you test this kind of frosting on a paper towel or a saucer before using it on your cake or cupcakes.

What is the most effective method of storing buttercream frosting?

Whether you’ve made frosting ahead of time or have leftover buttercream, it’s important to keep it properly refrigerated or frozen to prevent it from spoiling.

It is important to remember to maintain the buttercream airtight throughout the process.

Frosting should be kept in an airtight container or a piping bag with a rubber band around it.

If you’re preparing the frosting just a few days ahead of time, cover it in plastic wrap and place it in a dish with the frosting on the bottom.

What is the best method for softening refrigerated buttercream?

Cold buttercream may be used immediately after being removed from the refrigerator and put out on the counter to thaw for a short time.

It is best to defrost your buttercream in the refrigerator for a few days before using it. This enables the frosting to thaw more gradually, reducing the danger of temperature shock to an absolute minimum.

The amount of time needed to thaw frosting varies depending on the quantity and how it is stored frozen. Even if you keep the buttercream in a large container or dish, it may take many hours for it to become soft.

Remove Micron-Sized Air Bubbles from Frosting

A significant number of tiny air bubbles will almost definitely be present when the buttercream is brought to room temperature! Never fear, you can restore the silky smooth texture of your frosting by following these steps.

Using a paddle attachment or by hand with a rubber spatula at a low speed, simply combine the ingredients. Using a whisk or mixer, whisk or mix the frosting for a few minutes until all air bubbles have been squeezed out.


In this short article, we provided an answer to the question “can icing go bad?”, types of icings and we also discussed the storage method of homemade buttercream frosting.


Was this helpful?

Thanks for your feedback!