Can I use butter instead of vegetable oil in the cake?

In this brief guide, we will answer the query, “Can I use butter instead of vegetable oil in a cake?” and will discuss how vegetable oil can be replaced with butter.

Can I use butter instead of vegetable oil in the cake?

Yes, you can use butter instead of vegetable oil in the cake. Vegetable oil may be replaced with butter. Put in the same amount of oil and butter as directed (for example,  1/3 tablespoons of butter instead of 1/3 cup). Allow it to cool after melting. You may never use the oil again!

Replace the vegetable oil in the cake with this.

The fat in a cake has many functions. It adds richness and moisture to the cake, making it more delectable on the tongue. The taste of certain fats, such as olive oil, butter, and even lard or bacon fat, may make a dish stand out from the crowd.

The purpose of using vegetable oil in a recipe is to soften, enrich, and moisten the cake’s crumb, not to change the taste. To make things even easier, if you don’t have any oil on hand, you can just use vegetable shortening instead. Butter is perhaps the finest and most apparent substitute for vegetable oil.

Using Butter Instead of Oil

By replacing the vegetable oil in a cake recipe with butter instead, you accomplish two goals at once. First, since butter includes some water in addition to fat, it adds a little moisture to a cake. Second, and perhaps most importantly, it enriches the crumb by adding taste and richness. Adding butter, on the other hand, renders the cake inedible for those who must adhere to kosher or kashrut laws or have allergies to dairy.

The fact that oil is a liquid fat at room temperature whereas butter is solid presents an apparent problem when butter is substituted. While assembling the rest of the ingredients, melt the butter in the microwave to make a canola oil replacement or a vegetable oil substitute. To use, wait until it’s barely warm to the touch.

Making a Cake using Butter and a Box Mix

If you’re preparing a cake mix, replacing the oil with butter is a simple task. Butter should be sliced and melted in a microwave-safe measuring cup to ensure the proper quantity is being used. Sometimes the print lines on the butter wrapper do not match up with the stick inside.

Add the cold butter to the mixing bowl in place of the oil once it has cooled. Instead of just adding butter, you may also add a few additional ingredients to give your box mix a more handmade flavor. The addition of a few drops of high-quality vanilla extract enhances any cake, while fresh herbs and spices assist a spice cake, and so on. Bake the cake according to the package directions once it has been combined.

Making a Chiffon Cake with Butter

Oil is used in a surprisingly small percentage of homemade cakes. Most are chiffon cakes, but a few are chef-designed confections intended to highlight the fruity tastes of excellent olive oil. These are like angel food cakes in that they’re light and fluffy, but they have a deeper taste since they’re made with eggs and oil. Because fat has the unpleasant tendency of deflating your egg whites and taking away part of the cake’s fluffiness, they must be treated with care.

An important step in the creation of an airy and light chiffon cake is to include melted butter into the cake-like portion of the mixture before folding in the beaten egg whites. To thin the batter, fold in about 1/4 of the egg whites, then gently fold in the rest to retain as much of the egg whites’ foaminess as possible.

Butter/Oil Substitutions: Two Points to Keep in Mind

Up to a point, melted butter may be used to replace oil in a recipe in a 1:1 ratio. Because butter contains up to 15% water, it makes a difference when you’re preparing several recipes with it. It’s preferable to decrease liquids by a couple of teaspoons for every cup of butter when making a double batch of scratch cake or two boxes of mix.

Another thing to keep in mind is that the journey is only ever intended to be a one-way one. Because butter is solid and has a structural function in cake recipes, you cannot use oil as a replacement. Millions of tiny air pockets are formed in the butter when it is creamed with sugar. As the cake bakes, the gas produced by the baking powder or soda in the recipe is trapped in the air pockets. Because of the lack of butter, the cake will be thick and rubbery in texture.

To learn the other alternatives of vegetable oil, click here 

Other FAQs about Butter that you may be interested in.

Should ghee be refrigerated

How to store ghee?

How to store clarified butter


In this brief guide, we answered the query, “Can I use butter instead of vegetable oil in a cake?” and discussed how vegetable oil can be replaced with butter.