Can I substitute butter for vegetable oil in the cake mix?

In this brief guide, we will answer the query, “Can I substitute butter for vegetable oil in a cake mix?” and will discuss how to replace vegetable oil with butter.

Can I substitute butter for vegetable oil in the cake mix?

Yes, you can substitute butter for vegetable oil in cake mix. Butter may easily be substituted with vegetable oil. Use the same amount of butter as indicated in the recipe (for example, if 1/3 cup of oil is called for, use 5 1/3 tablespoons of butter). Melt it, then set it aside to cool. You might never go back to using oil again!

Cake mixes are a practical alternative to baking from scratch, especially if you don’t have much experience with baking from scratch. Most boxed mixes require two to three more ingredients, such as water, eggs, and vegetable oil, to bind all of the components together and add moisture for the perfect cake.

Other oils and non-oil alternatives can be used instead of vegetable oil to make a delicious, rich cake. Applesauce, for example, has the added benefit of lowering the calories and sugar content of your cake.

Can you use canola oil in the cake mix?

Yes, you can use canola oil in a cake mix. Canola has a very mild taste and works well with baked products. It is a good substitute for any other vegetable oil. Moreover, it has a high tolerance for heat, which comes in handy in baking.

So, what exactly is vegetable oil?

Olive oil, sunflower oil, canola oil, soybean oil, and other oils produced from plants are referred to as vegetable oil. Bottles of “vegetable oil” can also be found on the shelves of your local grocer. This product is made up of a variety of vegetable oils, with canola, sunflower, and soybean oil being the most common. It has a mild, delicate flavor and is frequently used as a moistening ingredient in baking.

What is butter?

Butter is a dairy product formed from churned cream’s fat and protein components. At room temperature, it’s a semi-solid emulsion made up of roughly 80% butterfat. It may be used as a spread at room temperature, melted as a condiment, and as a component in baking, sauce making, pan-frying, and other culinary methods.

Butter is a water-in-oil emulsion created by inverting cream, with milk proteins acting as emulsifiers. When refrigerated, butter stays a hard solid, but at room temperature, it softens to a spreadable consistency and melts to a thin liquid form around 90 to 95 °F.

Baking a Cake using Butter Instead of Oil

Using butter instead of oil in a cake might be beneficial since butter does more than keep the cake wet during baking. The butter and sugar are blended in most baked products, including cakes. The sugar grains cut through the butter, releasing air into the usually thick fat. The cake will rise more uniformly if butter and sugar are creamed together, resulting in a fluffier cake with a lighter texture.

The benefit of adding oil to a cake is that the batter is looser, which improves the cake’s texture and makes it lighter. When utilizing butter instead of oil, there are two approaches to achieve the same effects. To lighten the density of the cake and retain the texture as it should be, beat the butter and sugar for a few minutes longer than usual to include more air into the mixture.

If the batter is too thick and has to be thinned, add water to it. 1 tablespoon of water at a time, mixing well after each addition. Add as many tablespoons as you need to get the batter to the correct consistency for baking your cakes. Remember to add the items one at a time. It’s considerably easier to thicken a thick batter by adding additional water than it is to remove the water or add more dry ingredients.

In a cake mix, replace the vegetable oil with butter.

You may also use butter instead of vegetable oil while making your cake mix if you have any on hand. To minimize clumping and guarantee smooth, uniform distribution and texture, melt the butter before combining it with the other ingredients. Due to its richness, butter produces a somewhat denser cake, which is perfect for stacked, tiered cakes.

How much butter to use: Use the same amount of butter as vegetable oil.

Health advantages

Even though butter has long been vilified as an unhealthy meal, a study published in PLOS Medicine in June 2016 revealed that it is not linked to diabetes or cardiovascular disease. However, according to the study, you should not increase your butter consumption.

Is butter or oil better for cake?

Cakes prepared with oil have a texture that is often preferable to cakes made with butter. Cakes prepared with oil bake up loftier, with a more uniform crumb, and keep moist and soft for far longer than butter cakes. Cakes prepared with butter have a greater flavor than cakes made with oil.

Other FAQs about Butter that you may be interested in.

Can almond butter go bad?

Can you boil butter

Can you eat butter without a gallbladder?


In this brief guide, we answered the query, “Can I substitute butter for vegetable oil in a cake mix?” and discussed how to replace vegetable oil with butter.